alright. here is what i think will be the final draft. please feel free to print it out and send it to anyone in the media and/or government. feel free to use it as a template to create your own letter or to use it as an attachment to a letter of your own. the main thing is to use this as a springboard for discussion and awareness of an issue that gains importance as more and more people continue to have to fight this battle on their own. it shouldn’t have to be a fight that keeps happening in isolated corners of the country, where people face persecution unless they manage to get a spotlight to shine on their individual cases.
you can assume that you have my permission to spread this around, to reprint it, to quote it, to send it, or whatever.
please remember that i do not have a facebook account, so any questions or concerns will have to be posted on this blog if you want me to have access to them. (sorry for the bold writing just now- i wasn’t shouting; i just wanted to make sure you didn’t miss it!) i hope i have been able to take your feedback into account and reflect it in this final draft. i thank you all for your careful thoughts, and i apologize for any oversights. if you feel like i got anything wrong that you said, please let me know and i will try to correct it ASAP.
so now, without further ado…
Dear Sir/Madam:
In the past year or so, I have seen a growing assault on a specific type of individual freedom. A seemingly innocuous activity has drawn the ire of local officials, and when I tell you what it is, you will think it is so silly you just might laugh. You might even think that paying attention to this issue is a waste of your limited time, but I can assure you from my own personal experience that it absolutely is not.
In June of 2011 I faced a 93 day jail sentence for growing vegetables in my front yard. Yes, you read that correctly. There was no other issue, no hidden criminal mischief, no homeowner’s association, no history of any other violations. There was nothing in the municipal code that prohibited growing vegetables in the front yard, nor was there anything, unsightly or even vaguely menacing. Yet I was charged with a misdemeanor. If my case was an isolated incident, we could just attribute it to an overzealous city planner and that would be the end of the story.
But in September of 2011, Memphis high school teacher Adam Guerrero was ordered to dismantle a similar garden. In his case, he used the garden to educate students from the local high school about growing food, making soap and biodiesel, harvesting honey, and giving youth productive and constructive ways to use their time. For this he was dragged into court and labelled a troublemaker.
In June of 2012 Karl Tricamo of Ferguson, Missouri was ordered to tear up his front yard garden in spite of the fact that it clearly violated no zoning ordinance. He chose to stand his ground rather than capitulate to bullying by his city, but it was a difficult fight, and one that a law-abiding citizen should not have to wage. Karl won his fight too, but the city is planning to retaliate by drafting new and stricter gardening ordinances that will prevent him from continuing to plant in the future.
Perhaps most egregious, though, is the case of Denise Morrison in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Denise grew a varied garden of herbs, flowers, fruits, nuts, and vegetables. She was cited by her city for violating their zoning ordinances. And while her case was pending, before she had her hearing, city workers came and razed her garden. That’s right. No due process. no fair trial. All because some local bureaucrats wouldn’t tolerate one woman growing some of her own food.
So what can you do? I am asking you to be courageous enough to sponsor a bill that will protect a citizen’s right to grow food. I am asking you to pass into law something that should already be obvious to thinking people: that a free citizen should have the right (barring legitimate concerns over safety and welfare of others, of course) to grow food on their own property. Protect individuals from the petty tyranny of local governments.
Yes, I know we can vote in local elections, and we do. But wouldn’t it be wonderful if you took a stand on this issue? I’ll tell you who would support you, because they supported me during my fight with the city (which i won, by the way): people who care about: food safety, food rights, water conservation, energy conservation, organics, local politics, human rights, keeping government in check, farming, slow food, eating local, land use issues, environmentalists, water quality, peak oil concerns, saving money, healthy diets, teaching and learning, improvising in a tough economy, self-sufficiency, therapeutic benefits of gardening, creating strong neighborhoods and regaining a sense of community, taking pride in what you work for (a most American value), as well as many other things.
It used to be that Americans were encouraged to plant Victory Gardens. Average people felt they were helping their country and their families by putting their hands in their soil and growing some of what they ate. They took pride in the fact that they were able to see the results of their effort on their very own dinner table. Today many people struggle from paycheck to paycheck. Slogans are thrown around about how best to help people who are just trying to “make it”. Here you have case after case of people who are willing to do what it takes to plant what some have termed the new “Survival Gardens”. How wonderful it would be for them to be able to flourish in peace!
At the heyday of our battle, we had several hundred thousand visitors following my story on my blog. I’m sure there were at least that many following our story on other websites and through other media. Undoubtedly you would have more than that supporting you in this issue.
I will eagerly await a response from you.
Thank you and best wishes,
Julie Bass
Aug 08, 2012 @ 00:54:28
A+ !! Well done!
And kudos to You, because being new to Ohio, you have now successfully motivated me to figure out who my local reps are. Being a transplant from Los
Angeles, I am amazed people actually think in terms of Counties here. Never mattered Out West. And now I have to figure out who my State reps are. Darn, now I have to do some homework so I can send the letters. Your letter.
Thanks!
Grant
Aug 08, 2012 @ 01:23:58
Kudos for excellent letter. But you need to add an address because you say you await a response! It would be good if you had a P.O. Box so you could collect responses. Also, if an intelligent, caring legislator drafts a bill, it would be good to attach itt as an example for the less astute or lazy legislators, don’t you think? Seems like an huge task to keep track of and publicize the good giuys on this. Have you got the Take Back Urban Homesteading 5,000 members in the loop? Good work! Good luck!
Aug 08, 2012 @ 01:34:29
very nicely written, julie. NOW the ball is in OUR courts ….. to write a preface that will personalize this so that our own reps will actually see the relevance to their constituents {US!} – so that they will sit up and take notice and {hopefully} get on-board.
it will also enable those we send it to, to be able to respond to us in regard to our local ordinances, etc —- we’ll all {i’m sure!!!} keep YOU posted as to any/all feedback that we receive along the way.
{btw – my 3rd harvesting of blueberries this summer is almost ready [side yard]; my plums are plumping’n'purpling nicely [side yard]; my wild plum harvest just ended [front yard]; harvested 8 squash {3 diff varieties} [from front yard/bordering sidewalk] tonight …. carrots, tomatoes, bells, herbs, beans are daily [side & back yard]; watermelon, cantaloupe, pumpkins, gourds are jus’ comin’ right along [alongside the house] !
my point? in SMALL AREAS … along the perimeter of the yard and around the perimeter of the house – as “borders” …. i’m harvesting a great abundance of organically grown produce for my family {friends and neighbors!} … with late plantings for fall crops underway. ……………. all is attractive, and proves that it can be done with creativity & finesse; providing sanctuary for birds as well; attracting butterflies and {yes} bees …… all of which is a pleasant “hum-m-m-m” on a hot summer day!}
Aug 08, 2012 @ 02:21:49
Very well done!
Aug 08, 2012 @ 03:00:01
It’s TERRIFIC!.You have the basics and it would be easy for anyone to add a few lines to narrow down their specific issue without having to rewrite the whole format.Good job,Julie.Who knows where this might take us!
Aug 08, 2012 @ 06:56:05
It’s your letter, but I really hoped that you would explore the issue of how bad turf is and the absurdity of being legally required to grow grass.
I think this post covers the topic of how bad turf is pretty well:
http://www.beautifulwildlifegarden.com/the-american-lawn-is-not-sustainable.html
It isn’t just vegetable growers being taken to court over their gardens, People that plant natural-scapes for birds and butterflies are also running into this problem.
I think the issue should be about whether American home-owners should be required to plant grass, just because everyone else does…
*cough* lemmings *cough*
Aug 08, 2012 @ 10:00:35
Take out the “But” starting the 3rd paragraph, and go with, “Then, in …” or, just “In” again like the others. Otherwise, wonderful.
Aug 08, 2012 @ 14:10:43
ah- so i did that as a continuation of the thought that if it had just happened to me it would be the end of the story… BUT, it wasn’t … does that clarify?
Aug 08, 2012 @ 14:10:58
thanks- let’s hope!
Aug 08, 2012 @ 14:11:11
thank you!
Aug 08, 2012 @ 14:12:17
very inspiring!! maybe you could do a guest post in a few days on small space gardening? would you be interested?
Aug 08, 2012 @ 14:15:40
ok- i figured i would have an address on my own personal letter but that i wouldn’t put my home address up on the blog
and yes, if anyone gets wind of legislation being drafted, we should ABSOLUTELY post it here so i can post it up on the blog- great idea!
is take back urban homesteading april alexander’s page? would you be so kind as to post something there so someone from there could paste this up on their site?
Aug 08, 2012 @ 14:20:04
as far as you know, has anyone been required to plant grass? i wasn’t sure about that (except in my own case)- and i was trying to keep it to the broad issues. that’s why i didn’t specifically include the idea of jail time, since i was the only one facing jail time- i wanted to try to stay somewhat middle-of-the road here so i could deal with i thought was the most pressing right now and then i thought we could work outward from that. does that make sense?
The front yard | stonethegardener
Aug 08, 2012 @ 15:00:53
Aug 09, 2012 @ 23:16:59
I seem to remember a few years ago the M$M picked up a story about how some San Francisco residents were replacing turfgrass with astroturf with the rationale that, while not as ideal as no lawn, it would be a lesser evil–the latter doesn’t retain soil but the former is SO greedy when it comes to resource inputs–but IIRC the city council voted to put the kabosh on the astroturf.
Aug 09, 2012 @ 23:27:05
Part of me hoped the letter would address some of the classism I think is inherent in curb-appeal-as-public-policy, but there’s something to be said for coming in with a fairly short laundry list, and vetting out platform planks with which a majority of residents might happen to be in direct conflict. In jurisdictions in which there’s reason to believe a no-turfgrass option or even requirement has traction (I hear there’s been real progress in that area in the southwest), by all means add it to the letter for that audience.
Aug 09, 2012 @ 23:35:39
under the category of funny- completely NOT funny- within a month or so after my charges were dropped a senior citizen in oak park, michigan spent about $2,000 to replace his lawn with turf. he had always been meticulous about his lawn, but since he was getting on in years he couldn’t maintain it to the standard he was used to and it really caused him pain. he used money that he didn’t really have to put grass carpet type stuff so that he could look out his window and see nice uniform green with no weeds, even edges, etc. figuring that he could enjoy the years he had left looking out of his front window. the city came by and zapped him with fines and tickets and charged him under the same unsuitable/unlive plant material and he went in front of city council to plead poverty- he literally had no money left to tear it up, much less replace it… it was heartbreaking, and they were trying to figure out what to do about it, but would not wave the fines they put on him for failure to be up to code. ain’t that some stuff??? i actually forgot about him until just this minute…
Aug 10, 2012 @ 01:18:52
sounds interesting. something to consider indeed. let’s dialogue about this ….