i am awake absurdly early today. my migraine has settled into my left eye, so it looks like it’s gonna be one of those days…
i put away dishes, threw away stuff from last night, changed the garbage bag, and cleaned out gunk from the bottom of the dishwasher. i feel like, me being a bigshot farmer and all (
) i should say something more farmery- like, “ this morning i milked bessie and then cleared the back forty so we can plant our clover and put the animals out to pasture”. but, in reality, you aren’t reading the blog of a super-farmer. you are reading the blog of a suburban mom with a garden.
so, i cleaned the gunk out of the dishwasher .it’s not gritty or edgy, but there ya go.
i also read an article- i don’t even want to say the name of the paper because i don’t want people to read it- but it’s the detroit free press. it’s only fair that if i tell you my side, you should be able to read theirs.
the reporter who came out was soooooooooo nice- she felt like a friend of the family, and we spent a long time talking to her. the photographer came out yesterday, and she was also great. she was a bit incredulous at how small the garden is in real life- i guess the internet makes it look bigger??- so she was like, “is this it? i mean, is THIS what all the fuss is about?” (that’s not an actual quote, by the way- i just put in quotes for clarity…)
so, i just read the article- before i even had coffee, which, in hindsight, was a huge mistake.
i feel like (by the way, i hate when people say that- don’t feel, think!- but it’s crazy early in the morning, so you’ll have to cut me some slack) some of my quotes were put in the wrong context. i don’t remember saying exactly what she printed, although i’m sure i did, since she didn’t seem like the type to lie. when i reviewed the interview in my head ( 50 million times, right feythful? hahahaha), i remembered really poignant on-target things that i said. i think she quoted some wimpy non-poignant things, but i guess that was her call…
anyway, the weirdest part of the article for me was that the mayor of oak park has some weird conspiracy theory about our lawyer.
our lawyer (i’ll just call him OL, cuz i’m lazy…) heard about our case from a friend of my son. my son was talking to N. (names left out to protect the newly guilty) when the news came here, and a day or so later, N. was talking to OL and N. said how crazy it was that the city was ticketing us for having a garden in the front yard. OL said he would represent us for free. just a friend of a friend, doing someone a solid.
at that point, some people who read my blog had contacted local news stations. the local news people came out because the city was taking me to court for such a silly thing. that was it when OL said he would represent us.
OL heard our side of the story, and thought- like most sane people do- that what the city was and is doing is completely ridiculous. in fact, that’s the word most people use. but back to our story…
later, when OL talked to the formerly crushed-upon prosecutor, the prosecutor told him that the city would not be dismissing the charge. the city told him they DO NOT WANT THIS in oak park. i capitalized because it captures his insistence better than small letters. the city was prepared to go all the way (and not in a good sense, like when you go “all the way” in college…). so OL prepared his motions and briefs and other legal paraphernalia, and we set up a link to donate for the legal expenses, since it is clear this is no longer just a simple show-up-in-court-and-get-a-dismissal kind of case.
let’s cut to the chase. the mayor of oak park thinks OL has some kind of vendetta against him. he thinks OL is staging this to make him look bad in an election year.
so, i’m kinda wondering (cuz i’m a curious sort):
did OL arrange for kevin rulkowski to tell us that decorative plantings were ok? did OL somehow manipulate us into wanting to plant vegetables?
did OL connive his way into making me make that initial phone call, before he even knew me, and before kevin rulkowski became a household name?
did OL get the city to issue me a warning about not having vegetables in the front yard?
did OL write me a ticket?????????? (the nerve of him!)
did OL fail to dismiss this at the initial court pre-trial? or did he somehow bribe or corrupt the nice judge or the used-to-be-cute prosecutor to not dismiss the charges?
did OL talk to HIMSELF and say the city wouldn’t drop this case?
did OL say that the ordinance was correct and that the city had no reason to change it- and then TOTALLY FLIP that for the free press article and act like they want to work with me?
is OL behind this malicious prosecution just to get at the mayor?
give me a break!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i love a good conspiracy as much as the next guy (and sometimes even more than the next guy!) , but this stuff from the mayor is crazy.
and by crazy, i mean crazy- not ‘weird’ or ‘funny’ or ‘oh, i can’t believe it’- i mean really certifiably possibly needs to check for a head injury or a brain tumor (neither of which are remotely funny at all- i’m being serious here). i think there is something off about our mayor.
i have never actually spoken to the mayor. i’ve seen photos of him, but i don’t know that i would recognize him on the street. we have no grudge with him, no problem with him, and-AS A POINT OF FACT- he has never even spoken to anyone about this case, as far as i know.
i know this is getting long, but let’s review:
key players: KJ, the code enforcement guy; kevin rulkowski, who thinks suitable means common; the used-to-kinda-like-him prosecutor, who you will please remember i liked because he reminded me of someone else; the judge, who was nothing but fair and patient and even-handed; us, the poor sorry wretches who just want some fresh veggies (hahahah- ok, i took a little poetic license with that one!), and OL, who has done nothing sneaky or conniving or underhanded or untoward to ANYBODY in this case.
so, mayor of oak park- really?????? seriously, this is your theory about why oak park is prosecuting me?????????? i hope you really aren’t seriously ill…
and, detroit free press- really??? this is the article you chose to write???? after spending so much time with us, this is the final product you come up with??????
c’mon, people!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
Jul 12, 2011 @ 08:54:03
I feel I must react to your migrane settling into your left eye. That is an easy fix. Palpitate the muscles on the left side of your neck. You will find a vertical muscle that is very sore. Massage it out. If you can, grasp the muscle with your fingers and apply pressure. Otherwise, just massage it out. It will hurt, but massage it out. You will reduce or eliminate the pain. You may be left with a tired feeling, but the pain won’t be there. Your occipital muscle is in spasm and that is what caused your head-ache and now your eye pain. Love and Light to you.
- Linda
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:08:32
massaging as we speak. where is my husband when i need his strong hands??? oh yeah, he’s at work…
thanks -julie
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:57:24
About the migraines; I get them sometimes, and I get frequent bad headaches as well. I was taking a lot of pain killers and now I use 31 Herbal Oil and Juniper cream from SwissJust. Usually it takes them away, sometimes if they’re really bad it takes the edge off. So much so that I sell them now. You should look into them, and just so you know I’m telling you out of sincerity, I’m not even going to tell you how to contact me! lol Look them up. Also, my friend just found out that she’s got a gluten intolerance and that stopped most of her migraines, cutting out the gluten.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:22:01
ok- i’ll check it out!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 17:15:48
Hey Julie,
First off I want to say kol hakovod (for you non-Hebrew speaking folk – that means “you go girl” loosely translated). Your garden looks great. Can’t wait to see it in person. I hope your migraines get better. Have you tried an herb called butterbhur? A neurologist recommended it for me to use with my son (Yitzy) – who by the way also gets horrendous migraines. Hey maybe you can grow it in your garden, right?
-Shimra
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:10:28
I, too, get migraines. It’s usually during the winter, though. Have your kids take care of all the housework and seclude yourself in a pitch-black, silent room. It usually helps me!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:10:56
Also, migraines are associated with unusually high intelligence.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:37:40
What if its the right eye?
Jul 12, 2011 @ 08:55:44
Well, this is why few people pay attention to the main stream media anymore.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 08:56:38
did OL plant the tree that broke the sewer pipe? or maybe he stealthily snuck in and burst it and blamed it on the tree? “Holmes! Does your depravity know no bounds?”
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:07:20
oh my gosh- you are so right!! i didn’t even consider that, before he was born, he went around and planted a city-owned tree in front of every house in oak park
and then he must have been the one who dug down like 20 feet and busted the pipe and then cleverly concealed his actions by covering it all up (by hand, since he didn’t wake us up), and replanting the grass over it so we couldn’t tell. it’s all making sense now… i can always count on my blog readers to get to the bottom of things!! thank you- i shall summon the police immediately!!! (joking, city of oak park- JOKING!)
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:26:06
Hmmm… you may be on to something there. That was right before he flew to Hawaii and planted Obama’s birth announcement in the local paper.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 08:56:47
Julie – You have a ton of support (as if you didn’t know already) from all of your Old OPHS alumni.
Go get em’ Girl!
We love you and we Love Veggies!
Melissa (Silverman) Bouyounan
Jul 12, 2011 @ 08:57:12
On a positive note (cause I’m a glass is half full kind of person most of the time)…the one article I read today stated the mayor wasn’t going to send you to jail (not that I totally trust what he says)…that this was an “opportunity” to re-write the language of the law…Out of fear I think the conspiracy theory was born. Alot of people I’ve told this to have stated that the city needs a good “cleanse”. Press on…praying for you and your family!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:03:14
This case is the “poster child” for what is wrong with our government. You stand firm, knowing that 99.99% of people are behind you.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:03:31
Hi…heard about your veggies’ plight on Facebook.
In addition to you being a very spirited and plucky person for taking your stance, you are also one funny writer. Really enjoyed reading your blog posts. I sent a polite email to the Mayor of Oak Park just now, sketching out a few reasons why front yard veggie gardens should be a common and welcome sight in America, and suggested that the city completely change it’s position. And in fact, invite you to give a workshop on cultivating front yard veggie gardens, as you did such a nice and knowledgeable job with your own.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:26:46
hahahaha- my nice garden is totally due to ryan (the garden guru) and several other gardening friends- me giving a workshop on gardens would be like me giving a workshop on advanced mathematics- pretty much wrong all the way around
but thanks for being so nice! -julie
Jul 12, 2011 @ 14:08:34
B”H
From the depths of Central NJ I read of your plight — I have always thought that grass was a monumental waste of space, time and resources. Why not something more utilitarian like food???? What’s wrong with growing something humans eat? Do you have thousands of starving sheep and goats roaming your city’s streets? What possible objection could they have to growing veggies? Are they cannibals or total carnivores? Sounds like your mayor is a nut case (not a veggie case????) — does the word “paranoid” ring a bell????
http://bayitandgarden.blogspot.com/
Debbie
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:03:58
I am sorry you are having to go through all of this just to grow a few vegetables…
The reporter for the DFP sounds very unprofessional. It makes you wonder what the mainstream media actually does get right… not much, I think…lol
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:24:50
really there are some good articles out there- and the first two reporters who came out to us (alexis wiley and glenda lewis) were totally sweet and professional at the same time. the DFP lady was very nice and personable; i just think her story didn’t turn out so great. oh well, you can’t control what you can’t control, right?
Jul 12, 2011 @ 23:56:45
The story a reporter writes is not always the story that gets printed. Editors edit hard.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 12:34:25
Sounds like the DFP hasn’t changed much in the seven years since we lived in Livonia…not for the better, certainly!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:04:59
“If you don’t like what’s being said, change the conversation.” — Don Draper
The mayor probably does not like what is being said, but don’t let them change the conversation. It’s about vegetables, and the right to garden in your yard, not the next Oak Park election!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:05:29
why is this reminding me of Alice’s Resturant with the circles and o’s Ridiculous doesn’t even come close.
Would you like some Reiki for your headache? My migraines always end up over my right eye so totally relate!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:22:30
hmmmmmmmmm- does reiki hurt?
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:12:38
“Shovels and rakes and implements of destruction…”
Jul 17, 2011 @ 01:02:34
Big mean father-raper asked me “Kid, what’d ya get arrested for?”
“Planting vegetables”
And they all moved away from me on the bench…
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:08:12
Sounds like YOU are right! The good old lawyers for the better of themsleves…just like our Doctors now days and that can be another whole blog!! LOL
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:08:44
Oh, Julie! The plot thickens!! Do you think there’s a book deal in it somewhere? (Just kidding) I have thought all along there was something “wrong” with Mayor Jerry for even letting this become an issue. Is it an election year there? I bet Mayor Jerry wouldn’t want a big INTERNATIONAL (Yeah, they are talking this up in Australia now!!) smudge on his record. Best wishes girl; we sure would like you to stop by some of the sites I’m a member of as some are REALLY going to bat for you folks. I won’t mention the names here as I am not sure if you’d want me to. One fella is a well-known published author of “Peak-oil” books, has been on the History Channel, etc.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:11:33
love your blog….writing may be a new calling for you! I am going to go through old posts to try to find an email for city hall, but if you want to email it …I want to send some of the many photos I have of veggies in flower!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:12:29
I would be so proud to live next door to you, If I ever win the lottery I just might have to do it!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:23:18
I would be pleased to have *you* live next door to me. If I ever win the lottery, I’ll move your family out west here, to a town that’s not nuts.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:12:40
We small farmers are with you! Try a little lavender essential oil for that migraine dear one, just a dab at the temples and maybe one on your chin. Don’t get it in your eyes!
The world is watching – can you believe it!!? I have some predictions about the state of your local government but will keep them to myself, since I’m pretty sure you would share my outlook on that.
Where I live, we are a bit more old-fashioned/progressive. Isn’t that a weird thing to say….either that or the local rulers are too lazy to change the old codes. We can have chickens, even a small horse in our yards where I live or a goat or three.
My husband and I are planning on turning the entire yard into a food and flower garden eventually. It’s all about sustainability!
Hooray for local farmers! Even tiny wee ones. I predict that you won’t be sacrificed on the alter of stoopid guberment ofishalls. This debacle is totally insane.
Love – Linn (the herb lady of Irving Texas)
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:13:40
Stay true to your cause Julie; it is the right thing to do. Kevin Rulkowski is the laughing stock of the nation right now and the mayor is digging his own hole deeper with such ludicrous assumptions. You’re on the moral high ground and they don’t have a leg to stand on.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:20:21
From a supporter in the deep south. Good luck sweety! I sure hope that you manage to get enough sleep.
I’m sure that you fully understand by now that there is a huge amount of common people (I’m borrowing that lyric without any irony) standing up with you now.
The media and internet storm is, in a way, out of your hands. Like a garden exposed to the elements, you do your best to nurture it and guide it but slugs, vine borers , mildew, or hail will always be there, ready to pounce.
Just remember to stay strong and above all, stay healthy and grounded through what will surely be even more insanity; for your kids, your family, and yourself.
Again, good luck!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:19:59
thank you! (i kind of wanted to say y’all, you being in the deep south and all, but i don’t think i could really pull it off
)
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:24:43
Surprise- reporters lie, and they make up quotes. I’ve been interviewed dozens of times regarding my work at universities and research labs, and never did they get the facts more than half right. Not one editor ever called me to review facts, and nit one paper or TV station ever ran a correction. So don’t be too upset- your experience is absolute typical
Jul 12, 2011 @ 14:52:55
I’ve experienced this too; REALLY friendly, polite reporters take careful note of everything I say…which the next day is misquoted, used out of context, and ends up giving an entirely false impression, even getting very basic facts wrong. Often it’s not the reporters’ fault, but the editor may have political pressure on him, an agenda of his own, or simply be a nincompoop (amazingly common in local press)
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:30:21
I am driven to respond to your (plot!) plight and the ignorance you are being subjected to because I’ve had a garden all of my life and this is the worst case of stupid waste of taxpayer’s money I think I’ve ever heard! IS THIS ALL THEY CAN FIND TO DO??? Get real, people, and everybody in the city should go into their front yard and plant gardens in support of you and our civil liberties before we all get locked up because we breathe air.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:30:51
Methinks being bullheaded & singleminded may be a prerequisite to being employed in local government! I am fighting a similarly frustrating decision made by my provincial government. Keep up the good fight!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:35:34
You have almost 18,000 fans on the facebook page. A search on you name produces thousands of supportive articles (put “safe search” on though). At the end of the day, the mayor is attempting to defend a hopeless position using conspiracy and imaginary dictionary definitions. In the process he has brought ridicule and unflattering attention to the city he is supposed to lead. The mayor’s election results will be his own making.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:36:06
May I just say that the official webpage photo of the Oak Park City Council ***says it all***? What a bunch of schemey looking fatcats. Take a look, disgusting. Esp. after I just finished reading that Mr. Mayor is all “election yeary”. Again, disgusting.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:51:05
Well, you’ve made Daily Kos now!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:18:16
Daily Kos article:
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2011/07/11/993412/-93-Days-in-Jail-for-Planting-a-Vegetable-Garden-in-Your-Front-Yard?via=search
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:55:40
Wow… the Mayor actually believes all this “hoopla” has been instigated/manufactured by your lawyer to make him look bad during an election year? That shows: a) A tremendously inflated sense of self-importance; and b) A very sad lack of awareness of how truly important the issue of healthy food/self-sufficiency is to people.
How could anyone disregard thousands of emails sent to him from around the world as simply the election-year politicking in a small city? Boggles my mind…
Jul 12, 2011 @ 09:59:05
I think the photo on the Freep article speaks volumes. It looks like your children enjoy their upbringing and their Moms Garden. I find it very disturbing that the “educated bureaucrats” can’t see this garden for what it is. I guess they would rather your children were out getting into trouble as opposed to having and enjoying a home where parents educate and actually care.
As someone with first hand experience at some of the sights around Oak Park, I fail to see why they continue this madness..
p.s. I hope you get relief for migraine …:)
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:00:57
I left the Detroit Metro area a long time ago because I didn’t want to a be some outnumbered pioneer. The culture there is upside down to me. I decided to move to where I fit in instead of changing Detroit. You have my respect for being a pioneer though. Somebody had to step up. It takes a big person to do what you’re doing. Keep it up.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:03:43
I just heard your story on Friday and was so shocked. I live in VERY rural northern lower Michigan with a small hobby farm. So it never in my wildest dreams occurred to me that a city would discourage a veggie garden, especially one in beautiful raised beds like yours. Has your lawyer looked into the Michigan Right to Farm Act to see if you are in any way covered under that? Good luck to you and your family. I think the majority of the state, and possibly country, are on your side.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:17:54
he has looked into that- but just in case we lose, would you mind if we moved out to your farm and became squatters? we could put up a yurt or something…
enjoy your farm (i’m ennnnnnnnvious!!!) -julie
Jul 12, 2011 @ 21:21:19
You can put up a Yurt, but you have to help with the chores. LOL
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:20:43
I completely agree with you, Heidi, about the majority of the state being on Julie’s side. This is MICHIGAN for cryin’ out loud. What are we but a state of mainly rural and working class individuals that ranks very high in the national production of many fruits and veggies, including being NUMBER ONE in the production of vegetable-type bedding plants. Between the crazy winters and the crushing economy, what do we do? Buckle down, dig in, and figure out ways to survive including growing our own food! Live and let grow!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:11:39
Just read the “Mayor’s Message” on the Oak Park website – hysterical in light of this ludicrous lawsuit against you.
“Oak Park is known far beyond its boundaries as The Family City, a motto that reflects our community’s values and the goals of our municipal government” – so, to be clear, the “Family City” wants to jail a mother for trying to save money, feed her children high-quality, organic vegetables, and teach them about biology, food production, and healthful eating?
His second paragraph basically says the city is broke, has more costs than revenue, and is therefore severely curtailing services to citizens. Clearly, the mayor doesn’t realize there is a super-secret giant pot ‘o money just waiting to be frittered away on pointless lawsuits that benefit no one! Too bad none of this money can be used on providing citizen services (sadness!).
I think I’ve figured out why the city won’t back down on this – it’s right here in the Mayor’s Message: “The question is: What further steps must be implemented in order to ensure continued financial survival, and to possibly maintain the current level of services?” Obviously, the answer is to take you to court, and . . . oh, wait, never mind
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:22:30
Trully the case as it stands is outstanding in tis silliness. Objecting to four planting boxes on your lawn casts Oak Park in the position of an over the top overreaching government hardly enviable.
That said there is a real question for the courts as to what suitable means. Certainly suitable is not limited to just grass and flowers nor would a fully cultivated front yard with every inch plants with crops be considered necessarily suitable. The middle ground where a portion of the lawn is used for crops that do not grow very tall should be seen as suitable within the definition of the ordinance.
Frankly the reality of this case which I am certain is a jury a case as well as the pandora’s box of potential civil rights actions that could arise if there was a failure to accommidate you if Chas V’Shalom things do not go the right way as well all the negative fall out against Oak Park should all conspire for a favorable outcome.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:24:03
I saw that Time Magazine has an online story on this now, plus an editorial taking off from your story to talk about how lawns are totally useless.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 15:17:01
Here is the links to both Time articles:
http://moneyland.time.com/2011/07/08/woman-faces-jail-time-for-planting-organic-vegetable-garden/
http://moneyland.time.com/2011/07/11/vegetable-garden-controversy-revelation-front-lawns-are-useless/
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:24:37
Does Hizzoner realize this story made Drudge Report? That his ridiculous ordinances and selective enforcement have made Oak Park the laughing stock of the nation??
It’s not a conspiracy. Never chalk up to malice what can easily be attributed to stupidity. In this instance, it’s an overreaching bureaucracy alone.
Stick to your garden boxes!!!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:26:29
Hello from Pa !
I just finished reading your story on FB from a Rodale note this morning and I also watched the video. What a great garden and soo much work! The first question that came to mind is, who is paying your mortagage ? your neighborhood ?
And the second thing I thought about was, that it’s amazing how much time people seem to have these day’s,to worry soo much about what folks do with their property instead of whats going on in their state and country !
I wish you well with your garden and hope everything turns out ok for you and your family ! ~ Peace
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:26:29
If you were misquoted in the paper, the mayor probably was too. Best to just talk to the mayor directly and forget the bad journalism (or editing….) of that particular paper. Too many “news” outlets try to make controversy where there is none. Or where there might be some, but not what they try to drum up to drum up readership. Take everything…… everything….. with a grain of salt. And good luck with the migraines. I get them too and I love all the suggestions you’re getting here. Focus on the support, not the bad journalism. “Water the seeds, pull the weeds.” (It’s not just about gardening.)
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:35:31
You have even more right to plant vegetables than this guy and he won! http://www.newschannel9.com/articles/city-999896-terry-planter.html Yay for free speech with toilets and vegetables!! Maybe you should mention this case to your lawyer for precedent.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:36:32
Julie, I can’t believe this is happening to you!!!! We sooooo support you. We were in Detroit this past weekend (Kranczer bar mitzvah) but didn’t get a chance to stop by. If I had known how BIG this issue was becoming, I would definitely have stopped in, taken photos, etc. The whole thing is outrageous! I’m subscribing to your blog so that I can keep up with what’s going on. We will be moving to Cleveland some time in August so will make it back to Detroit for visits more often. Stay strong. By all the comments here, you have a lot of support. Much love to you and your family.
Chana Rogow (Richard, too!)
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:44:15
and back to you! my daughters are so excited to hear from you!!!! i hope you love cleveland- things haven’t been the same for us there since abba’s closed… anyway, great to hear from you!!!!! -julie
Jul 12, 2011 @ 10:50:02
You’re doing a good thing, a right thing, even though I know from experience it’s frustrating and tiring and feels like it’s a fight over a very small thing.
I signed the petition and politely pointed out that the city is trying to move against the “urban ag” tide, and they’re making you into a hero and themselves into villains–as well as making their community look bad–in the process.
This is NOT your intention I know, but this fight would be a very good point over which to organize and run new candidates for local government office. That might be a good place for your local supporters to funnel their energy.
Best regards,
Rebecca
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:04:00
Might be a good thing this is happening in an election year. You can tell the city council that it has become an international news story now. Oh, and if you want to be quoted in my blog (auntiapathy.blogspot.com), just let me know. Posted an entry yesterday which mentioned you.
Best of luck!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:04:03
Can I do anything else to help?
I did Sign the online petition, currently writing an e-mail to send to the oak park people don’t worry i’m not going to be mean or hateful. Just asking them to let you keep your garden.. “unless you have some witty words I can send?” I am following all blogs that have your name in them.
This hurts my heart so bad, I just heard about this on 89x this morning amazed at how some people don’t feel the same. Makes me cry, what’s wrong with this world, will the world not be happy until we are all cloned.
I don’t know I want to do more to help. Once I get paid I’ll be donating some money to you as well. I’m blogging about it and how it rips my heart to shreds. I’m not angry just really really sad and disappointed in humanity. (not all of them…
I just feel like i can do more to help. Please contact me anyway you can and let me know what I can do to help. Sorry i’m not from oak park but i’m in wayne county.
You have my full support people like you do give me some faith in humanity. Wishing you and your family and friends the best. Good luck!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:34:28
oh gosh- you are really too sweet, and it seems like you are doing pretty much everything that can be done. i appreciate your words so much!!! thanks to people like you, i am inspired to keep doing what i’m doing. thank you, really- julie
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:07:40
I just found out about your situation via Twitter. I’m a mid-20′s historian and pro-local-foods lady from Columbus, OH, and I just wanted to let you know that you’ve got my support.
What is this world coming to if growing vegetables is a criminal offense? What’s next? “Drop that milk, little Billy! Everyone knows that’s a contraband substance!”
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:42:47
only if it’s raw milk- hahaha- NOT ;0 -julie
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:12:22
I read this appalling story and watched the news video a few days ago and it’s since been on my mind a lot. Aren’t we at war? Isn’t this a victory garden?
How is her garden any different than a fruit tree in a front yard? Or a pecan tree? A grape arbor? A few basil or chive plants between the lollipop shrubs? What if she plants sunflowers to eat the seeds? Will we start looking at motives next?
The disconnect between people and nature/food over the last century is scary and I’m glad this story has brought the issue to light for discussion. I also don’t understand the desire for “sameness” that seems so prevalent in neighborhoods. What’s wrong with being different and interesting – as long as it’s “tidy?”
Wages do not keep pace with inflation and it’s riduculous to try to stop anyone from feeding their family by growing food on their own property that they paid for and pay taxes for. This mentality that it’s unsightly to grow food crops is ridiculous and I’ve never understood it. There seems to be a thread of “why can’t you afford to buy your chemically poisoned food at the grocery store like us?” Would it be preferable if she goes to get food stamps? I’m not saying this particular woman from this story is in that position but a lot of people are. They aren’t amusing themselves, they’re trying to have food to eat and instead of asking for help, or more help, they’re using their land to help themselves.
I didn’t see any weeds and it looks very tidy. I know most municipalities have regulations against weeds over a certain height, certain types of weeds growing at all, and against having a junk yard in your yard. An ordinance against industrial/farming equipment and work trucks is also common. She is not doing any of that. The problem must then be a prejudice against *certain* food crops. If that’s not it, then it’s against using *certain materials* to build a garden bed. All I can see is wood. I’m sure MANY of her neighbors have beds and walkways bordered by wood.
What are people thinking when they make a law against growing a veggie garden? Please tell me if you can. I can’t get there on my own.
The city official didn’t even say there’s a law against a veggie garden. He said the law said “suitable” which he said was defined as “common” in the dictionary. I looked at dictionary.com and didn’t find the word “common” at all. It defines suitable as “appropriate; fitting; becoming.” This garden is completely appropriate, fitting, and becoming for a family and especially during a recession and while we are at war.
Loved the poem, btw…
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:18:53
Patti Moreno, the GardenGirl who has an urban sustainable farm in her yard and wonderful youtubes quoted Oxfam as saying something like 50% more food will have to be raised in coming years. What better place to start than on one’s own property? You go, girl!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:21:38
Also, a local elementary school in Charlottesville, VA has a garden for the children as a teaching space. So much can be learned from a garden!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:25:27
I’ve been following you since I saw the picture of your yard published in the Lovely Listing blog. I believe in property rights and find it upsetting that they are doing this to you. I don’t tend to comment much on blogs but know I am a supporter and I am watching.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:27:17
I don’t know why the Free Press printed the article they did, but I do notice that tends to be the case when it concerns something not quite ‘mainstream’. As Ghandi said, “First the ignore you, then they mock you, then they fight you…then you win.” So you’re in the mocking stage with the paper, and the fighting stage with the government.
I know why you perceive there is something wrong with your mayor. It is a disease endemic in all politicians today it seems. He is a sociopath. They have no ability to think about anything except in terms of themselves.
You should run for mayor when this is all over, you know
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:30:50
Not that I’m implying you are a sociopath, but that you’re not, and it would be a refreshing change for your city
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:33:55
Just read the article in the Freep . . . I found the end of the article the most interesting:
“We’re not against vegetables. This has nothing to do with vegetables or gardens,” Naftaly said.”
Wait a minute!!! “This has nothing to do with vegetables or gardens”???? It has only to do with Naftaly’s re-election (previous paragraph)???? REALLY?????
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:35:30
I read the Freep article last night– it’s just spin, and pretty obvious spin at that. It’s the flip side of the issue: there are NO regulations against a front yard vegetable garden in the wording of the City regulations, and EVEN IF your attorney has “political aspirations,” the Oak Park Mayor and City Planner have done everything possible to play right into this. THEY have made an issue where, across the country, there is none, It is OKAY to be self-sufficient. It is COMMON for communities to allow vegetable gardens in homeowner’s front yards. It is APPROPRIATE for Oak Park elected officials to take responsibility for their behavior and apologize. They abdicated the opportunity to LEAD a positive change.
llegitimi non carborundum. You are an international heroine.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:39:58
Hi, Julie-
My first comment, but I’ve been reading your blog right along. I’m another OP resident who supports you. At least the Freep got your name right. I swear I saw a Det News article that called you “Jane.” Looks like they fixed it online.
I’m getting mad that I voted for all the city improvements, if this is how they’re spending my tax money. Keep us posted on the court date if they don’t back down. I’ll try to be there!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:31:52
yep- i was “jane” for a while. i was a bit worried that my husband had another gardening wife… he called the writer and she changed it. at least she was paying attention when she interviewed me- NOT. hahahaha- gotta laugh sometimes or you just cry…
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:45:59
Maybe your mayor is not dropping the case because your city/town needs revenue ( as most towns do now). Maybe all this publicity is ( in some strange way) ” good for business”. Maybe he is getting backed up by large lobbying efforts, like that of Monsanto Corp., those that are desperately fighting organic gardening and and ” suburban” gardening in general. I just read a “plea” of sorts that was actually written by your mayor on the town website. Here’s the link http://www.oakpark-mi.com/mayors_message/index.asp. Maybe you can come up with a ” conspiracy” theory of your own, one that may be based more on fact than fiction. If you need some help, contact me………………I am an expert in research………………..
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:30:23
hahahaha- i will keep that in mind!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 11:50:40
If you are going to give interviews to the media, I strongly recommend that you buy yourself a tape recorder of some description, and tape any interviews. I find it keeps everyone honest, more crucially, you can actually review what you said for yourself. That way when you read your interview you assure yourself you haven’t wandered through the looking glass!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 12:00:43
Wishing you all the best. We have a similar case here in B.C., in a semi-rural area. A couple took an abandoned strip-mined gravel pit and created and organic mini-farm. Council decided it was against zoning. We have a dying planet on our hands and this is how some people use our precious energy? I don’t GET it!
Anyway, here is my 2 bits on your behalf, sent to Kevin R, cced to mayor and whatver other email address Mike Adams posted. In the spirit of catching more flies with honey than with vinegar.
Dear Sir,
I understand you are doing your best to maintain standards
of all-over niceness in your jurisdiction. You may have asked
ms Bass to refrain from growing a vegetable garden in her
front yard with the best of intentions. I could totally see
your point if it were an overgrown mess.
However, the place looks perfectly nice, and times are changing.
The treat of food shortages is real. This poor planet is being
poisoned to death. And we are running out of oil.
Lawns demand expensive oil-based fertilizers and pesticides.
They are part of the problem. Ms. Bass nice-looking veg beds
are part of the solution.
Are you a big enough soul to join the forces that would like to
save this beautiful creation for those who come after us?
I fully understand it can’t be easy to backtrack from an
official position. You have my sympathy. But imagine the power
of the precedent.
“Local official gets more information on issue, gets a different
perspective, and changes mind…”. Wow. What a concept.
Wishing you fortitude and wisdom as you struggle wit the issue
of how to make Oak Park the nicest possible place to live.
Ien van Houten
Nakusp, B.C.
P.S. If it is on my planet, it is my business….
Jul 12, 2011 @ 12:14:32
Julie
Have you ever thought about a conspiracy what really is behind your
troubles with Oak Park officialdom? I am alluding to the “free Masons”
a cabal of members of this evil organization might be working together
to effect an outcome not of your liking. “Masons” are a very powerful
group of citizens who have an allegiance first to other members, They
exist in most cities, and they control the local government. Their members
hold key positions of power as mayors, city council, police, media, courts, etc.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 12:16:34
Hi, I live in southeast Va and garden for my sanity. ‘Nuf said about that – some solutions that could perhaps calm the tempest in a teapot about your sweet veggie boxes (what I’d give to have edging like that, mine is nothing but mulch that my two outdoor kitties scatter around when they mark, yeesh!) –
Butterfly bushes/buddleia – it grows faster than imaginable – you can put a hedge of it along your curb/roadside – it attracts the most amazing swallowtails (always ONE zebra swallowtail each spring, you’re lucky to see it) but you have to capture the praying mantissessesss esssss (!) that lie in wait – I release them down in our woods – put them on your veggies, don’t let them kill butterpies!
Coneflowers are tall – black-eyed Susans are tall – anything along the roadside that qualifies as flowergarden-worthy plantings can screen your nice beds. Sunflowers, too, those big tall varieties…Compromise like that until the plantings are bigger would really have to shut down the naysayers, don’t you think? I mean…botanical gardens are full of those very plants – bee balm is another one that reaches three ft or more given nice soil and mulch and you can’t beat it for feeding bees and ‘pies. Do you get hummingbirds up that way? They LOVE bee balm…
Do some research on Betula Nigra/river birch trees – I’ve planted them for years; they have lovely dappled shade and amazing bark – and they won’t grow deep enough to trash your pipes (just tore out massive white maple that ate our septic field pipes – $9,000 pile of maple at edge of woods now, oy!). Up where you are, Paper birches are awesome. The river birches grow just that fast, however – if they grow in your region.
Best of luck to you, Julie…
fran
Jul 12, 2011 @ 12:27:19
Julie
Best not to think about this…..but the odds are that in the middle of the night
vandals will visit your front lawn and destroy your vegetables and herbs
long before you are able to harvest them…..
Hope you have an infra red surveillance camera and recorder to catch the action.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 12:41:11
Julie, I just found out about you on line, and have just discovered your blog. Wanted to share MY front yard city garden (we’ve moved to the country since I first had it.) and also that there are front yard vegetable gardens all OVER the place. Just Google Front Yard Vegi Gardens. http://www.google.com/search?q=front+yard+veggie+garden&hl=en&client=firefox-a&hs=Wsg&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&prmd=ivnsu&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei=7HccToOcE4KasAOfvqC7BQ&ved=0CEgQsAQ&biw=1306&bih=625
Here are two links to MY personal garden in our front yard when we live in the middle of the city. http://www.flickr.com/photos/minetothine/sets/72157622421400686/ and a video of it… please ignore my stupid voice. lol http://youtu.be/-so3kzhzzQ4
AND just so you know. No one EVER vandalized my garden in the front yard.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 12:44:43
Just read about your case on treehugger.com. Wanted to give you my support! The city is being absolutely absurd. Your front yard is beautiful AND functional. It doesn’t get any better than that! Also, wanted to make a couple of points. One, if “flowers” are required for the front yard, you’ve got them! Lots of veggies produce flowers (squash, tomatoes, peppers, cucumbers, herbs, etc.). And, two, if your veg garden is a problem for not being “common”, is it possible to rally neighbors to plant some veggies in their front yards so that it becomes common? I’d do it in a heartbeat if I live in your town! Garden solidarity, sister!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 12:45:08
I admire your wry humor in the midst of such adversity. I’ll keep it short – you have plenty of comments to read –
1 – NEVER TRUST JOURNALISTS!
2 – To be fair to the Mayor, I’d never trust lawyers either – except pro-bono ones – OL qualifies, so yes, trust him.
3 – Never trust politicians – (e.g. Mayors and elected folk)
4 – Trust Sumatriptan to get rid of Migranes – ask your doc about it. Only thing that works for me.
5 – Gardening is relaxing – or supposed to be!
Poor you – thinking about you and sending you support all the way from California.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 12:59:36
Bummer about the paper putting what you said into a different context, etc. I wanted to chat with you about dealing with the press, that’s the main reason I wanted to talk to you via phone.
They always come in with an agenda, but you can use them to your advantage to get your message out. Decide the main points you want the public to hear, and if you’re asked a question that you don’t feel is relevant then change the subject in your response. You can do this several ways, for example, you can say, “I don’t really feel this is the main issue, the main issue is XYZ.” Or you can say, “That’s one approach to this issue, but the more important issue is XYZ” Make them work for you! The press isn’t used to this, so they may seem taken a back at first, believe me, I’ve seen it happen. They won’t be happy, but they don’t need to be happy – you need to get your story out the way you want it presented. I got this info. from a book my husband got from a college class called “Organizing for Social Change.” The book is used in a university in the mid west, (can’t remember the name!), that was started by Martin Luther King Jr. among other social activists. Many have used their principles and have been quite successful in getting their message out in the media. So remember, you don’t have to answer every question directly, use the questions as bridges to the message you want put out there. You will be amazed when you use these principles! Hope that helps, and don’t worry about the article. It’s one of many, and you can always respond in the comment section to clear things up, which will be seen on the net at least. You could also write a letter to the editor, or contact the writer and explain to her that you feel you were misrepresented. I’ve done this and the writer was happy to make a correction to the article. Keep up the good work! April – fellow house wife gardener and activist
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:13:57
I truly believe its a campaign from Oak Park city to promote more vegetable gardens like the one at The White House.
Or a joke.
Or you are close to your anniversary and its all part of a plot to a big party, later at the Courthouse.
I refuse to believe you are a REAL criminal, and you are going to Court, to Trial, with a Jury, and can be sentenced to JAIL.
Cannot be true. Simply can’t.
Its too stupid to be true.
No.
For vegetables?? tomatoes? cabbage? basil?
Jail? 93 days? 3 months? Its surreal.
I’m sorry, but I refuse to believe it. Can’t be. Not in my country.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:26:54
i’m right there with you, alexander…
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:15:31
I just wanted to let you know that you have my fully support in everything that’s going on. I only first heard about your plight this week, and I couldn’t believe it! If I actually had a front yard (I live in Israel, in an apartment that has no yard), I might be inclined to plant a vegetable garden myself. I have no green thumb to speak of, but my oldest son has expressed interest in being able to pick vegetables/fruit to eat instead of having to go to the grocery store to buy it. Growing a garden is a lovely project to do with children.
By the way, I love reading your blog. I see that you haven’t changed at all since you taught me in high school. You’re still young, fun loving, and enthusiastic about everything. I’m glad to see that you’re able to view all of this in good humor.
A former student of yours,
Rena (Berkowitz) Traxler
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:38:26
oh, wow- it’s so great to hear from you! i had no idea you were living in israel- tell your son he is my hero! and thanks for the compliments- so nice to have a fan club
hope we can be more in touch now that you’ve found me! take crae- julie (aka mrs. bass)
Jul 13, 2011 @ 08:31:46
Yes, it was really nice to find you! I told my parents about this story, and they couldn’t believe that Oak Park officials have nothing better to do than to stop people from growing front vegetable gardens. It’s so utterly ridiculous, and surreal! My father says they are likely to be extremely embarrassed in court. What jury would put you in jail for 93 days over this? lol
Anyway, yes – I’ve been living in Israel for the past 7.5 years. I have four children now. If you send me your email address I can email you some pictures if you’d like.
I’ve always enjoyed having you as a teacher, and this story reminded me that you taught us civics as well. Now this would be a cool court case to take us to on a school field trip. lol
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:17:29
Truly this is a squandering of resources in economically challenging times. The absurd nature of this case in particular only highlights the dubious nature of Oak Park’s position.
The broader issue, how far can a municipality go in regulating behavior especially on private property. Certainly a front lawn because it faces the public should be more regulated than a backyard. Certainly cultivating every inch of a front lawn may not look pleasing and may be inappropriate for a residential neighborhood. However what Ms. Bass is doing should be appropriate and consistent with the ordinance except under the most tortured of readings.
It is remarkable the City of Oak Park does not get this. Indeed it is this failure of common sense that should concern us all.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:18:43
Soon, very soon, you’ll come to realize that “The Press” is not your friend. They have an agenda. It’s ALL political. Just like the Mayor. Politics. Period. Oh, yes and in case you hadn’t heard: Politics is about money and power which equals greed. What? your puny little garden is about money, power and greed? Yup. You may not be old enough to remember the sunday comic strip called Pogo. There’s a famous line from one of the strips that people used to quote. “We have found the enemy and it is us.” That’s right we are THEIR enemy. However THEY can keep us subjugated, they will.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:20:11
Love your post, a snatch of my own sarcasm in there. Have you harvested any veggies yet? I for one would also love to watch the progress of your beautiful plantings. As for the mayor, he shows us exactly what politicians are made of. We are rooting (no pun intended) in Tennessee!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:25:34
not yet on the veggies, but we are ever hopeful
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:26:56
Off-topic for today’s blog, but have you seen FRESH? It’s a very positive movie about growing fresh, sustainable, organic vegetables, and there’s a whole piece on urban farming. (A viewing of it might also be a great way to help fundraise.) Check it out! http://www.freshthemovie.com/
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:29:04
Wait, there’s an election coming up? You should run for an office on the platform of promoting community gardens, front yard gardens, and changing the local ordinances to support those gardens! Even if you don’t win or even really want the “job,” it would be a great campaign.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:25:04
oh gosh no- i couldn’t juggle one more thing. seriously. but thanks for your vote of confidence!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:31:36
Also (sorry for so many replies!) it really cheers me up how the issue of your little front yard vegetable garden has brought together people from so many different issues. I read conservative voices, liberal voices, concerns about the environment, concerns about private property, free speech issues, health issues, urban planning, economics…and they all have joined in supporting you and your garden!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:34:38
I just read the article, and it’s ok. I know it can be very frustrating to talk to a reporter for so long and then feel like he/she picked out the least interesting things you said. Reporters sometimes work a little too hard to balance out both sides of a story. Overall I think you still come out looking like the sane one. I mean:
“It was highly unusual. I had said she couldn’t do that. I never in a million years thought she would actually do it,” said Rulkowski.
We’re talking about a vegetable garden….
Jul 12, 2011 @ 14:03:31
I, too, just read the article. You came off looking great. Your quotes were right to the point (“Why do something that’s decorative and useless,” she said, referring to flowers. “Vegetables are good for kids, and growing food is a real process.”) This is a caring, thoughtful response to the insanity you have to put up with right now, so cut yourself a bit of slack.
I think you should be pleased with this – the article is slanted to your side of the argument and that reporter got the mayor to commit in print to revisiting the ordinance – I think you may have some leverage in the future to change what your town deems “suitable” front yard plantings!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:41:02
And somewhere, OL has the “new code” that will be implemented in a few months, without a grandfather clause to protect you, so you (OL) will get to go through this again next year! LOL
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:44:50
I thought the free press article was pretty even handed but I know what you mean about being misquoted. I was once involved in a situation that received media attention and it was frustrating to see my words taken out of context. And even though what they wrote wasn’t wrong, it didn’t paint the whole picture correctly either.
And I totally LOLed at the conspiracy theory of the mayor’s.
Good Luck!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:47:45
Trully this is a squandering of resources in ecconomically challenging times. The absurd nature of this case in particular only highlights the dubious nature of Oak Parks position.
The broader issue, how far can a municipalty go in regulating behavior especially on private property. Certainly a front lawn because it faces the public should be more regulated than a backyad. Certainly cultivating every inch of a from lawn may not look pleasing and may be inappropriate for a residential nieghborhood. However what Ms. Bass is doing should be appropriate and consistent with the ordinance except under the most turtored of readings.
It is remarkable the City of Oak Park does not get this. Indeed it is this failure of common sense that should concern us all.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 13:52:19
This could all be eliminated if your neighbors would just plants gardens in their front yards….then veggies WOULD be common
Jul 12, 2011 @ 14:09:44
More support coming from Davis, California, to you, Julie. Vegetable gardens are beautiful symbols of hope in my opinion and I wish everyone had them on their front lawn. Even the fraternity house across the street from me has a garden on their front lawn. Your integrity and good manners combined with your unyielding stance on this issue are so admirable. Regardless of what your city officials decide, you have won much more – you’ve raised awareness of an important issue and you are reminding us of the importance of growing food and standing up for what you believe in.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:19:52
thank you!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 14:11:42
http://www.vegetablegardener.com/item/10844/should-you-take-out-all-or-some-of-your-lawn
Great Website on the value of gardens over lawn!
Also – remember that Victory Gardens were encouraged by the government
Jul 12, 2011 @ 14:13:01
Hang in there! I called the numbers and planted the seed – think Victory gardens instead of picking on someone with 6 kids to feed in this economy. Hope the more positive change in perspective will take hold and yield a more positive result for you and all the way around for Oak Park and the rest of us as well.
God Bless!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 14:13:48
Dear Mr. and Mrs. Bass,
You may not think yourself qualified to give gardening workshops, but since this is a chance to rewrite the ordinance, you do have working knowledge of that. It is time for the city to face the times and needs of its citizens. Since the greedy robber banksters brought the economy of this nation to its knees, we are in a recession/depression (depending on one’s bank account), but just as bad, inflation WILL follow – meaning the price of food will only go higher. Local governments must be responsive to the needs of its citizens, and its citizens have the need to grow their own food: chickens, bees, and gardens in the most sunny spot available – the now forbidden front yard. ………..
The city needs to recognize that times have changed, not only are lawns the wrong thing to plant, but that people’s ideas of a nice front yard have also changed. Americans are the most spoiled people on the planet and some of the most hated too because of that – we are gas hogs and water hogs. A lawn uses inordinate amounts of water unnecessarily as well as needs poisons dumped into the ground leaching into our water or killing animals or birds with its residues. My definition of ignor-ance is to ignore education when it comes one’s way. The city needs to do better research on how other communities have urban gardens/farms in front yards – not to mention to be responsive to its citizens needs. There is a recession/depression (depending on your bank account) going on. . Again, cities must adapt to changing times, and that is what you have done. ……….
I hope you and OL can assist the city with its need for education and its the new ordinance.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 14:19:36
I completely support your garden.
(I have a garden, small, in my own front yard, where the only sun is.)
Note: there are a lot of people who automatically dismiss writing involving multiple exclamation marks, question marks, etc. as over-emotional or downright non-rational. Be cautious in your typing.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:18:59
ok- i tend to write as i speak, but maybe i will try to be a bit more aware !!!!!!!!!!!!!????????????*********&&&&&&&&&&&- just kidding!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 14:34:30
Does Oak Park have a convenant about how your front yard has to be maintained? Unfortunately lots of towns do. If not apologize profusely and make a bigger garden next year. You can also say that you following the example set by Mrs. Obama. After all the White House belongs to the United States and she didn’t ask my permission
Jul 12, 2011 @ 14:44:36
I feel your pain with the reporter mis-quoting, or otherwise spinning the story off in their own direction….I volunteered for years trying to protect a beautiful open space parkland in California, and every time we were interviewed, no matter how carefully we crafted our statements, stuck to the messaging, etc, the story always came out with some wacky distortion making us look like sue-happy envirohippies. That’s why the real PR speciailists are so good at what they do…I think the only way to manage it is to hold a press conference or give out a press release and truncate the interview, but that may be a little odd for a renegade gardener, I suppose!
Good luck, we support you from NC!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 14:47:28
The media never represents things as they really are. But one good thing that came out of this article is that it is really getting your story out! I would have never heard of you if not for my husband emailing me the article. I would love to have a garden in my front yard but we agreed to live in a neighborhood with an association that regulates EVERYTHING. Oh, how uneducated I was! Anyway, keep up the good fight, we are behind you 100%. Hope your migraine goes away!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 15:24:27
I’ve read about your conundrum but not all the articles, so you might have already heard this. Many vegetable plants are used ornamentally. For instance Kale, chili peppers and herbs. I have fennel decorating my front lawn mixed with purple cone flower, lilies and carnation. I use the carnations and fennel for salads. Does that make them less attractive? Who is to say what is acceptable as a form of landscaping. It’s a matter of taste. (Frankly, I’ve seen some yards that were designed by professionals and they looked less attractive than our vegetable area. Oh yeah, I’m also decorating with pumpkin vines and luffah sponge plants. The flowers are magnificent.)
Jul 12, 2011 @ 15:25:51
I’m sure other people have told you this already but be careful about what you say here. They will use anything they can against you when you finally go to trial and you can be sure they are sparing no expense to make an example out of you.
How dare you question their authority and to have the audacity to use your yard in a constructive, environmentally friendly, and eye pleasing way.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:15:30
is there anything you think i said that i shouldn’t have? i tend to be pretty transparent, but if you think something is over the line, please let me know. thanks! -julie
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:00:33
Fellow Oak Parker here! Glad I found your blog! I fully support you and your veggies! I toyed with the notion of planting my veggies in my front yard, and decided against it only because I was worried about people stealing my crops. LOL
Guess I made a good decision there. Stupid Oak Park. Where are you, btw? I don’t read the paper, and would LOVE to see the offending garden in person and would love to shake your hand!
I am now a loyal follower. I’ve shared you on facebook, too. Peace.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:21:44
Can I do anything else to help?
I did Sign the online petition, currently writing an e-mail to send to the oak park people don’t worry i’m not going to be mean or hateful. Just asking them to let you keep your garden.. “unless you have some witty words I can send?” I am following all blogs that have your name in them.
This hurts my heart so bad, I just heard about this on 89x this morning amazed at how some people don’t feel the same. Makes me cry, what’s wrong with this world, will the world not be happy until we are all cloned.
I don’t know I want to do more to help. Once I get paid I’ll be donating some money to you as well. I’m blogging about it and how it rips my heart to shreds. I’m not angry just really really sad and disappointed in humanity. (not all of them…
I just feel like i can do more to help. Please contact me anyway you can and let me know what I can do to help. Sorry i’m not from oak park but i’m in wayne county.
You have my full support people like you do give me some faith in humanity. Wishing you and your family and friends the best. Good luck!
Not sure if this posted hope it’s not a double post.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:22:09
Watching your story with interest from the other side of the state. There are a lot of people on your side! http://blogs.babble.com/strollerderby/2011/07/12/michigan-mom-faces-possible-jail-time-for-planting-front-yard-veggie-garden/#comments
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:27:52
Julie I think it’s my fault! Just like the reporter said
Yesterday when I came over. ” this is all your fault for making the raised beds”. I decided to start making raised bed gardens for people, with the soul purpose of taking down the current Oak Park government.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 16:44:17
You have my sympathy for the silly city codes, but I also don’t think it’s healthy, for your kids especially, to eat foods that are grown so close to exhaust fumes. It helps that you have (apparently) used soil from elsewhere – otherwise you’d be facing high probability of lead contamination from your lawn soil – but the exhaust fumes in the air are absorbed by leaves and also soil, and taken up by the produce. You can’t just wash it off. There are guidelines on the internet – i think it’s a minimum of 20 feet from driveways and streets, more if the streets are heavily travelled. I think you’re a victim not so much of the silly city code, but of the backyard gardening movement that puts out victory garden hype and doesn’t tell you the dangers of planting near cars, old houses, streets where soil has lead from years past, etc.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 18:24:26
yep- i was informed today by the host of a gardening show. but i’m thinking i’d still rather have car exhaust in the air than chemical garbage sprayed directly onto the food. call me crazy…
Jul 12, 2011 @ 17:14:51
Hello Julie,
I’ve been following your story since you only had about 430 signatures on your petition! Apparently, you did not set out to change the world, but thank you so much for changing the world! Your situation has so clearly set a paradigm shift in motion. It is exciting to be at the starting moments of this movement of consciousness. The national and international dialogue about sustainable agriculture, small-scale self-sufficiency, and personal property has been amazing to witness.
I grew up about 10 blocks from you and now live in the rural northern outskirts of the Detroit area. (I only know this because your house looks exactly like my childhood next-door neighbor’s.) You wrote that you are not Rosa Parks, but she was just tired of being tired and stayed seated. You clearly just want a garden and reasonable city codes to follow. Thank you for staying seated or standing up as this case may be. You are truly a heroine in all the best senses of that word.
Hope to be there on the 26th in solidarity.
Peace and happy weeding!
Diane
Jul 12, 2011 @ 17:15:48
More about migraine…I help get rid of mine, and you aren’t going to like this with coffee enemas. Google it. They use it at the Gerson Institute to detox the liver.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 18:22:29
eeks- i’ve heard of it, but can’t say i’m on board… thanks for trying, though
Jul 12, 2011 @ 18:34:55
Ms. Bass;
Thank you for your efforts in ‘doing the right thing’. I’m sorry that the city put you in this position and am grateful your standing up to them. I wish you well and will be watching your situation.Your garden is beautiful.
If your neighborhood is anything like ours, the front yards of others vary in maintenance from well maintained to lackadaisical. I looked briefly on Google maps to see what the state of lawns appeared to be in Oak Park, and found some green, a few brown, and others with a lot of bits of detritus strewn about. Google certainly isn’t definitive, but it gives a sense of the community.
So my question to the city is, are they enforcing this “suitability” clause equitably? Are they ticketing people with brown lawns, leaf strewn yards, flower gardens that are properly deadheaded, etc? Is the city maintaining it’s own public spaces to this standard?
Anyway, I’d love to see more pictures of your community and hope for the best outcome for you and your family.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 18:40:14
You can also just try drinking a small amount of coffee Julie. I’ve tried it and it does work sometimes for mine. I’d rather do that then go the enema route any day!
Thanks for the call back, bummed I missed you. Hope to chat soon!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 18:58:30
I love what you are doing, bucking the system. The city should be pleased that you are willing to show the neighborhood kids how to grow and eat cabbage and cauliflower….they are gonna need to know sometime…I say when the crop comes in, have a veggie party, invited the mayor, the chief of police oh and the press! Stick with it!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 19:01:25
What happened at the hearing on June 26?
Jul 12, 2011 @ 20:54:07
been there, done that- on june 28th, i think. the next pre-trial is july 26th. mark your calendar!!!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 19:05:55
The Food police at work, coming to a city near you if we don’t stand up to them. It can never be a crime to grow food anywhere on the planet one is born on.
The true story behind this is that the corporations who sell us “Phood” want us to be dependent on them for it. Just imagine the consequences if EVERYONE had a veggie garden in this country?
Jul 12, 2011 @ 19:10:44
Please please PLEASE……fight those city bah-stards. They should be nominating you for citizen of the month for growing veggies in your front yard, not taking you to court. What you really ought to do is post the mayors photo, and email address online, so those of us that support you can flood his in box. Don’t let them intimidate you, don’t give in, and don’t give up! Almost EVERYONE is in your corner on this!!!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 19:15:30
Here is your tag line Julie…
Let Bass off the hook!
haha
Jul 12, 2011 @ 20:49:39
are you the jane evershed who makes the amazing beautiful pictures? because if you are i have your “she could not be reached” in my bedroom. if you really are, i might faint. seriously (gasp)- are you???
Jul 12, 2011 @ 19:19:24
I signed the petition because I feel that they are wrong in doing this to you. It is your right to have a garden and it doesn’t have to be in the back yard like some may think. The law is unjust and ridiculous. Good luck. I do hope you win this.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 19:23:29
Disregard my previous comment, please. I thought the hearing had already taken place! Best of luck to you on your fight!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 19:25:03
About your garden. What a wonderful idea. Grow your own food! Who would ever think of such a thing! Oh wait farmers and anyone else in their right mind that can do it, has the time and patience. Bravo to you. It doesn’t surprise me the city needed to be involved. Make them prove you’ve broken a law. Then when they try to pass one for the future EVERYONE object. They have just passed a law here in Denver allowing people to keep chickens in their yards. Also in California in some areas people are allowed to have chickens and other fowl.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 20:47:00
yep- i’m so jealous!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 19:26:09
In the wilds of PA, reading your posts and your troubles. Crazy, crazy stuff. Hopefully you’ll get a book deal (“Dealing wth Local Politicians For Dummies”, perhaps?) or some other good karma out of all of this. Good luck!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 20:46:36
i’ll go for the good karma, thanks!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 19:40:52
You are growing more than vegetables in your front yard, you are contributing to an increased awareness of how wonderful, economical and healthy it would be for more people to grow edible landscapes. I love seeing all the comments on your facebook page that share ordinances and shifts that are happening in localities all over the USA that are embracing the concept of growing gardens in urban landscapes.
Rigid thinking is pervasive in so many areas of our society. I think your city government and its employees are missing an opportunity to widen their perspective and do something innovative, positive and hopeful by revisiting their front yard ordinances. Maybe it is fear of change, or a strong hold on wanting to be in control, or most likely it is a myriad of reasons it has come this court session. I like to think it is because the issue is bigger that just your front yard and your town, that it is something that needed some stirring up nationwide.
You may be helping to start many home gardens, in front yards and in back yards, that would never have been planted or even thought of without reading about your situation.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 20:32:03
well hurray for that, elsah! you make me so happy
Jul 12, 2011 @ 22:07:23
Why don’t you plant some colorful flowers throughout the garden. Then, it will be a flower garden.
Jul 12, 2011 @ 22:25:01
I shared your story on my blog here: http://ibelieveinbutter.wordpress.com/2011/07/12/growing-vegetables-can-be-a-one-way-ticket-to-jail/
rooting for you!
Jul 12, 2011 @ 22:40:38
Dear Ms. Bass,
I am totally on your side with this case. I would love if it actually went to trial, needing a jury. Hell, if you need someone, tell an attorney I’m unemployed and have plenty of time to be one of the jurors.
Seriously, I would think the town would put a halt to this if it should get that far, just due to the tax dollars involved and the embarrassment of it all.
Oh, and when I looked up suitable, nowhere did I find that word to mean, ‘common’. If anything, it’s purely subjective, depending on what it’s
considered appropriate.
Also, your front yard looks to be at least 50% lawn/sod or even more. If they want to play hardball, credit should be given to you for that at least.
Hang in there! Rooting for ya!
Chad
Sparks, NV
Jul 13, 2011 @ 01:57:46
I really feel your frustration. I posted something on the General Forum. Again is your city run by lunatics!!! Seriously I know some people in Mental Institutions that are in there for less than this sh$t thinking. Here in Australia; we are discouraged to have lawns/pretty flowers etc because of the waste of water. We have a house in our street with a vegie patch in front garden surrounded by large rocks ….. they share the excess with other families with kiddies. Good God; with the economy down the bloody toilet; high food prices; unemployment HIGH; and don’t get me started on obesity; you’d think THEy would be encouraging this for all people. Here some empty public land is given to people in council/welfare housing flats to encourage them to grow their own. Maybe THEY should take a tour DownUnder and learn how to govern RIGHT. I hope you kick ass. cheers; vera; in Melbourne; Australia
Jul 13, 2011 @ 09:54:57
go, australia!!!
-julie
Jul 13, 2011 @ 03:36:32
you have a beautiful website , I wish you a nice Wednesday greetings from Germany ღDreams☆of☆Shadowღ
Jul 13, 2011 @ 09:50:00
dank! (hope i spelled that right…)
Jul 13, 2011 @ 05:53:35
Hi, Julie, fran from Va again…I was on the road yesterday, thinking of your plight. The word “suitable” basically means “appropriate,” the way most of us use it all the time. “Your shorts and tank top are not suitable for court [church, wedding, bar mitzvah!].” “This isn’t a suitable amount you want to pay on this bill, sir.”
Obviously, “suitable” would have ranges of discretion. You can’t just decide to wear shorts and a tank to see the judge – or not wear a tie to a fancy restaurant; they’ll hand you one. Discretion in some events or situations is out – you are at the whim or wish of the person in charge, like the judge or the chef.
Something as diverse as a yard and a garden and what qualifies as ornamental or functional/organic/educational would by its nature vary in “suitability.” Yards where alot of children run and play and pound the grass is going to be subject to the “green lawn, nothing but green lawn, and oh, yes, some roses” notion? Or yards where an elderly resident can’t maintain that height of perfection each week?
My plants have put me on the road to recovery after open-heart surgery, clot issues, anticoag problems, all in my mid-40s from congenital problems; otherwise I’m healthier than a mule. My garden is my realm of what I give I get back. It’s therapy. It’s my little Eden. Winston Churchill built his many walls at his estate to soothe “the black dog” of depression, and he painted. Who can dictate what pastimes we choose as Americans when they are safe (your garden won’t land any of you in the ER) and inexpensive and building family ties? Thomas Jefferson spent decades researching and importing plants to his plantation at Monticello. Ol’ TJ was plowing up the lawn and putting peppers all over the place and we study his notes to this very day. You can grow a vineyard like he did and create another great Michigan wine! Just sayin’…the story here lies in the rigidity of your city’s leaders. There is no story on your end of it. Except how many new friends you’ve made! Cheers! Sante! Shalom!
Jul 13, 2011 @ 09:23:37
I think mayors are all a little paranoid. It’s part of the job.
Jul 13, 2011 @ 09:28:03
If you need some type of reference or supportive material to present in court, I would recommend looking at a book called, “Redesigning the American Lawn; A Search for Environmental Harmony” by Bormann, Balmori, Geballe.
Another book is good for understanding how people’s view of, uses of, and opinions about “front yards” have changed as society changes… Where did all this grass come from? It is “The Lawn; A History of an American Obsession” by Virginia Scott Jenkins.
I became interested in this issue years ago when I bought a house. I wanted to own my home, but was not interested in spending hours every week slaving away to maintain and mow the grass lawn. Once I realized the impact of having so much mowed grass everywhere, I was compelled to change half of my grass for flower/veggie beds.
Although I think you can “hang your hat” on “suitable” and “Michelle Obama” to win this case, it never hurts to be fully and comprehensively prepared.
Jul 13, 2011 @ 14:54:21
Bless you for this particular info I had been exploring all Bing to uncover it!
Jul 14, 2011 @ 13:47:59
I love your sense of humor. It will keep you sane, unlike someone in your narrative, who is clearly a grumpy and paranoid fellow…. probably abused by a renegade carrot in his formative years.
At any rate, I am a front-yard veggie-grower-Grandma, from the Central coast of California. SO your story is very near and dear to my heart.
Keep up the good work, Sweetie!
Debbie K